The Courier’s special series of debates on the independence referendum began on Thursday evening at the Gardyne Theatre in Dundee.
A large audience of around 300 made sure it was a lively event.
Our panel was Mark Diffley of Ipsos Mori, SNP Treasury spokesman Stewart Hosie and Scottish Liberal Democrat leader Willie Rennie.
The debate was chaired by The Courier’s political editor Kieran Andrews.
See below for updates as the debate happened, and see full reports and photos in Friday’s Courier.