Plans to remove a memorial to two youngsters killed in a road accident to make way for a sports pitch have sparked a storm of protest.
A Scots pine and memorial bench in the grounds of Perth Academy stand in the way of the council-led development.
In the eyes of many, the loss of the tree is not outweighed by the benefits of the new facility and a large number of objections have been lodged with the council.
Among the objectors is Perth Academy teacher William MacDonald, who says in a letter: “This tree is a landmark in the Viewlands area and has probably been there longer than the school.
“It has also been used as a memorial to two pupils killed in a tragic road accident.
“This tree was chosen by the pupils of Perth Academy to mark the lives of these two pupils, they raised funds to pay for a seat and a memorial plaque, which have been placed under the tree.
“Plans can and should be adapted to leave this tree and the seat in place for the pupils who treasure it.”
Pupils have shown their displeasure at the plan by tying a yellow ribbon around the trunk of the tree.
The proposal is for a pitch for football/hockey, which will be used in an intensive fashion for school and club use.
“The pattern of use could mean that the playing surface is subjected to 60 hours per week of use,” says a report which will be considered by councillors next month.
The sports pitch would also involve constructing a five-metre-high fenced enclosure and eight floodlights.
Apart from the memorial aspect that would be lost, objectors are complaining about such a historic tree being cut down and the impact of the floodlighting.
“I am concerned about the light pollution caused by the floodlights, and would like a guarantee that they will be used within restricted hours, and that they will be hooded, shining only on the pitch,” said Mrs Sarah Bell.
“Secondly, measures need to be taken to reduce noise pollution, again with restricted hours, both during construction and once the pitch is in use. The creation of banking/foliage to block out light and noise should be considered.”
She also said the memorial aspect of the tree should be taken into consideration.
Former academy pupil Tom Fincher wrote: “My primary concern is that one of the best Scots Pines in this area will be lost should this development be approved.
“This tree holds many special memories for me (and others, I’m sure) and is a fantastic example of this tree species. It provides a landmark on this vast, open playing field area which will be sorely missed should the development be approved.”
He said that, if left alone, the tree could live for many more years, providing a shaded, quiet place for children to sit and relax.
Mr Fincher added that bats may use the tree to roost and he would welcome consideration being given to relocating the pitch.
The council said the application is expected to be considered by the development management committee next month.
“We can’t really comment on it at the moment as it’s a live application,” said a council spokesperson.
“The issue of the tree/bench and memorial has been considered, and will be outlined in the report to committee that elected members will base their eventual decision on.”