Councillors have defied planning officers to sensationally approve plans for a new Kirkcaldy supermarket.
Members of Fife Council’s central area planning committee have approved plans by Lidl to develop derelict ground at the west end of the Esplanade.
It came despite claims from the region’s planning officers that the development would do little to enhance the western entrance to the town.
While some councillors did not support the plans, passionate pleas from several committee members appeared to carry sway.
Neil Crooks, the chair of the Kirkcaldy area committee, said: “I have lived in Kirkcaldy all of my life and been area chair since 2012.
“This site could lie derelict for another 20 to 25 years.
“It can be good to have blue sky thinking on a site but if they fail to produce anything then it will look like Victoria Road.”
Lidl hopes to develop the site, directly opposite rival chain Morrisons, and move from its current premises just several hundreds yards along the Esplanade.
The move is expected to create an additional 15 jobs, with the retailer having hinted that expressions of interest have been shown in taking over its current store.
However, planners had recommended refusal of the plans, stating that the development would create an unflattering entrance to the west end of the Esplanade, though denials were made about the role of the site in any future plans for a cross-Forth hovercraft terminal.
Councillor George Kay supported Lidl’s plans, stating that there was more chance of Elvis returning than a hovercraft crossing being established.
He added: “Here we have got someone 700 metres away that is wanting to expand its business and that does not have any impact on the High Street.
“We have been given an opportunity and we must grasp it.”
However, not all councillors were convinced, with John Beare stating:
“It’s a difficult judgement call for all of us.
“There is no guarantee that the existing premises will not become idle and a tip.
“I think this could suck more life out of the town centre and I propose we support the recommendations for refusal.”
The decision was approved by eight votes to four.
jowatson@thecourier.co.uk.
