A study has exonerated Montrose Port Authority of contributing to the erosion crisis in the town.
A Coastal Process Assessment refuted the link between the port’s dredging activity and coastal erosion in Montrose.
Montrose Golf Links – battling to save the 455-year-old course from a watery grave – has pointed the finger at the port for “wasting” the dredged material by dumping it at Lunan Bay.
Links director Chris Curnin claimed if the material was put onto Montrose beach in the “correct” position it would have a “significant impact and slow down the erosion”.
The port has made public the findings of the assessment undertaken by leading marine consultancy ABPmer, whose key objective was to “provide a comprehensive understanding of the coastal processes operating in Montrose Bay”.
Montrose Port Authority chief executive Nik Scott-Gray said the study has disproved the previously-reported link between the dredging of MPA’s navigation channel, subsequent material dumping to the south of Montrose Bay, and the ongoing frontage erosion at Montrose Golf Links Limited (MGLL) to the north.
He said: “The information provided on the coast process and morphology of Montrose Bay illustrates that there have been phases of both accretion and erosion of the beach and dunes since 1865.
“The cycle of change witnessed at Montrose is common along the east coast of Scotland, as patterns of wave activity in this area are multi-directional, and can result in changes in direction of longshore sediment transport.
“In other words, any link to port dredging and coastal erosion was made on classification of Montrose Bay as a self-contained sedimentation system, whilst in fact, coastal change within Montrose Bay is not unique and is controlled by far wider influences than those within the bay itself.”
The assessment goes on to confirm that episodic weather events – in particular wave direction and height – are linked to the greatest rates of coastal erosion in the area, which took place during the early 1990s.
This period also coincided with the production of a lower volume of dredged navigational channel material.
Mr Scott-Gray said this would indicate the sediment released from the dune cliffs at this time did not increase the volume of sediment dredged by the port and released elsewhere.
In addition, the study has also provided options for future protection of Montrose Golf Links, including any opportunities to utilise maintenance dredge material as beach nourishment.
He added: “As the current Angus Shoreline Management Plan for MGLL states a policy of ‘no active intervention’ it is unlikely that regulators will approve construction of further hard defences along the frontage.
“Whilst this should still be a considered option, we believe that the disposal of dredged material within Montrose Bay could also provide some coastal management benefits.
“However, the Coastal Process Assessment confirms that for any significant effect, consistently large quantities of material would need to be pumped ashore onto the upper beach.
“By commissioning this study, it is clear that – whilst MPA is happy to consider involvement in a beach replenishment programme – several factors must be considered: MPA is currently legally bound to dump its dredged material outwith Montrose Bay; the variable amount of dredged material available each year may not provide sufficient protection; and finally, the process of pumping quantities of material ashore will require a substantial financial commitment from the Scottish Government.”
Representatives from the Links met with cabinet secretary for the environment and climate change Roseanna Cunningham earlier this month to discuss the issue of erosion.