Highland Spring has said it has paid for “significant flood defences” over the years and is committed to protecting the business, catchment area and the wider community – where possible – from flood risk.
It comes after a councillor queried if public money was effectively being used to fund a flood protection scheme for the Perthshire-based bottled water company.
SNP councillor Jack Welch asked the question as a council committee approved proposals for a flood protection scheme in Blackford.
The recommendations for the flood scheme at Blackford were approved by Perth and Kinross Council’s Climate Change and Sustainability Committee on Wednesday, November 16.
‘It seems a bit odd’
At last week’s meeting Strathmore ward councillor Jack Welch said: “My understanding is there has been some capital works being spent effectively to prevent flooding associated with the Blackford Highland Spring plant.
“Ultimately they are a significant landowner – effectively catchment in that immediate area.
“They can – I guess – perform flood mitigation measures on their own land so it seems a bit odd these things aren’t approached in tandem.
“Is it the public purse that is providing flood mitigation measures for a private company? Yet that private company could be providing certain mitigation measures in their own right?”
‘Encouraged to protect their own assets’
Perth and Kinross Council’s interim flooding manager Peter Dickson said there was a community approach that could benefit residents, businesses and other organisations indiscriminately.
He added: “There is that question – and it’s a good question – should those companies and businesses who are well able to do something themselves?
“We’d certainly encourage Highland Spring to protect their own assets there.
“One thing we do often do – and we can’t force it – is we ask for a contribution to our flood scheme from a business or a big landowner who will definitely benefit from it.”
Company ‘has undertaken some works’
Flooding technician Gavin Bissett added: “They have undertaken some works themselves just to defend their own site.
“But certainly with the wider scheme we have had some higher level discussions with them so they have been involved in the process.”
Mr Bissett said there were “wider projects off-line from our scheme going forward currently as well”.
Highland Spring response
After the meeting a spokesperson for Highland Spring told the Local Democracy Reporting Service: “Highland Spring Group are committed to environmental sustainability and protecting our business, catchment area and the wider community, where possible, from the risk of any flooding.
“We have worked hard over many years to put in place significant flood defences across our site and land which have been paid for solely by the business.
“We have supported Perth and Kinross Council with data required for their flood modelling study and await further details on the final proposals.”
Conversation