A dispute over plans to turn a Dundee 19th Century mansion into flats rumbles on despite the developer altering the plans following objections.
The original plans for a residential complex of 29 apartments, some of which would have overlooked one of the homes on nearby Cedar Grove, have been changed to incorporate 19 flats.
Although the structure would no longer overlook the existing house, an extension to the original building to create three houses continues to be a bone of contention.
Resident Susan Ashton said that she would still object to the new plans.
She explained: “I acknowledge that the plans have changed for the better, but there is still too much development at the back of Anton House.
“To put three houses at the back is ridiculous – the most that should be there is a small bungalow.
“Everything is too big, that’s the problem – it should be half the size.
“The houses would still be blocking our only south facing window and natural light.”
Chamberlain Bell Developments, which initially withdrew its plans, has resubmitted its bid.
Alan Bell, technical director at Chamberlain Bell Developments, said the firm respected the objections from the local community.
He said: “There were obviously a few objections, the main one was that there were too many flats proposed.
“We believe we now have a better mix of properties to appeal to a number of buyers including period properties, penthouse flats and family houses.
“There were concerns from the local community which we have taken on board. Our amended plans have been made in order to satisfy those objections.”
Mr Bell said it was hoped work will begin in July, provided the proposal is given the green light.
Anton House had previously been used by Capability Scotland as a day-care centre for adults with disabilities.
He added: “The majority of the original house will remain and be refurbished, with demolition work being carried out to a small out house building and timber frames located in the grounds.”
The new application was submitted by Fouin + Bell Architects Ltd on behalf of Tranos UK & Chamberlain Bell Developments Ltd last week.
John Watson, planning secretary for Broughty Ferry Community Council, said it was “imperative” that early work takes place on the site.
He said: “The community council was in support of the previous application and believed it would have benefited the area in due course.
“It’s good news that the developer has taken notice of local concerns regarding the site. This application has been a long-standing issue.”
